How do you assess and improve your phishing awareness and prevention program?
Phishing is one of the most common and effective cyberattacks that can compromise your IT security operations. Phishing is the fraudulent attempt to obtain sensitive information or data, such as usernames, passwords, or credit card details, by impersonating a trustworthy entity in an email, text message, or phone call. Phishing can lead to data breaches, identity theft, ransomware infections, or financial losses. Therefore, it is essential to assess and improve your phishing awareness and prevention program regularly. In this article, we will discuss how you can do that in six steps.
-
Nebojsha Antic 🌟🌟 230x LinkedIn Top Voice | BI Developer - Kin + Carta | 🌐 Certified Google Professional Cloud Architect and Data…
-
Umang Mehta25x LinkedIn Top Voice 🏆 | Global Delivery Head | CISO | CISA | Global Thought Leader Top 10 IT Leadership | Global…
-
Chris WojzechowskiGeschäftsführender Gesellschafter bei AWARE7 GmbH | Experte für Informationssicherheit
The first step is to define your goals and metrics for your phishing awareness and prevention program. What are you trying to achieve? How will you measure your success? Some possible goals are to reduce the number of phishing incidents, increase the reporting rate of suspicious emails, or improve the knowledge and behavior of your employees. Some possible metrics are the click-through rate, the report rate, the accuracy rate, or the feedback score of your phishing simulations, training sessions, or surveys.
-
Umang Mehta
25x LinkedIn Top Voice 🏆 | Global Delivery Head | CISO | CISA | Global Thought Leader Top 10 IT Leadership | Global Top 50 CyberSecurity | SOC Expert | CySA+ | GICAST | PCI DSS | DFE | EHE | Writer | Researcher
The importance of defining goals and metrics for a phishing awareness and prevention program in order to measure success and improve employee behavior.
-
Chris Wojzechowski
Geschäftsführender Gesellschafter bei AWARE7 GmbH | Experte für Informationssicherheit
Um die Effektivität eines Phishing-Sensibilisierungs- und Präventionsprogramms zu bewerten und zu verbessern, können verschiedene Metriken festgelegt werden. Dazu gehören die Phishing-Erkennungsrate, die Klickrate auf Phishing-Links, die Erfolgsquote bei internen Phishing-Tests, das Feedback der Mitarbeiter, die Reduktionsrate von Phishing-Vorfällen, die Zeit bis zur Meldung von Phishing-Angriffen und die Teilnahmequote an Schulungen. Durch die regelmäßige Überwachung und Analyse dieser Metriken können Unternehmen die Wirksamkeit ihres Programms beurteilen und gezielte Verbesserungen vornehmen, um die Sicherheit der Organisation zu erhöhen.
-
Craig McDonald
We stop email threats others miss 🛡️ mailguard365.com | Enhance your Microsoft 365 security | Trusted by startups and industry leaders like Porsche | Endorsed by Satya Nadella | Non-techie CEO
Establish relevant metrics and key performance indicators (KPIs) to measure the effectiveness of your phishing awareness program. Metrics may include the click-through rate of simulated phishing emails, the report rate of suspicious emails by employees, the accuracy rate of identifying phishing emails, or the feedback score from training sessions and surveys.
-
Jason Soper
Cybersecurity Guardian | Safeguarding Clinics & Patients | Defend Boldly. Rest Easy.
To assess and improve phishing awareness, define clear goals. Such goals can include increasing employee understanding of phishing, enhancing detection skills, encouraging reporting, and reducing click-through rates on phishing emails. Key metrics can include the success rate of phishing simulations, reporting rates, training participation and completion rates, time to report phishing attempts, the frequency of successful phishing attacks, and employee confidence levels. Regular evaluation of these metrics will pinpoint the program's effectiveness and areas for improvement, bolstering the organization's cybersecurity stance.
-
Jafar Hasan, CISSP
CISSP | CC | ISO 27001:2022 Lead Auditor | CRTP | CEH | (ISC)² Candidate | Information Security Consultant | Bug Bounty Hunter
Begin by clearly defining the objectives of your phishing awareness and prevention program. Identify what you aim to achieve, such as reducing the number of successful phishing attempts, increasing employee awareness and reporting rates, or improving overall cybersecurity posture. Establish measurable metrics to track progress towards these goals, such as phishing simulation click rates, reporting rates, and overall security awareness scores. Aligning your program goals with specific metrics ensures that you can effectively evaluate the program's effectiveness and measure its impact over time.
The second step is to conduct a phishing risk assessment to identify your current vulnerabilities and threats. You can use various tools and methods to assess your phishing risk, such as phishing simulation tools, email security audits, domain name system (DNS) analysis, or social engineering tests. These methods can help you evaluate your email security posture, your domain reputation, your staff awareness level, and your potential attack vectors.
-
Craig McDonald
We stop email threats others miss 🛡️ mailguard365.com | Enhance your Microsoft 365 security | Trusted by startups and industry leaders like Porsche | Endorsed by Satya Nadella | Non-techie CEO
Deploy phishing simulation tools to conduct realistic phishing campaigns and assess employees' susceptibility to phishing attacks. These tools simulate real-world phishing scenarios, allowing organizations to evaluate their email security posture and gauge the effectiveness of employee awareness and response to phishing threats.
-
Umang Mehta
25x LinkedIn Top Voice 🏆 | Global Delivery Head | CISO | CISA | Global Thought Leader Top 10 IT Leadership | Global Top 50 CyberSecurity | SOC Expert | CySA+ | GICAST | PCI DSS | DFE | EHE | Writer | Researcher
The importance of conducting a phishing risk assessment using various tools and methods to identify vulnerabilities and threats in a company's email security posture and staff awareness level.
-
Major Abhinav Prakash
Amazon I IIT I IIM I Indian Army I AI - Analytics I Risk & Investigation I Physical Security I Information Security I Privacy I Data Security I
A phishing risk assessment is a systematic evaluation of an organization's susceptibility to phishing attacks. Phishing is a type of cyberattack where malicious actors attempt to deceive individuals into providing sensitive information, such as login credentials or financial details, by posing as a trustworthy entity. To conduct a phishing risk assessment, organisations typically follow these steps: 1. Identify Assets 2. Evaluate Existing Controls 3. Phishing Simulation 4. Vulnerability Analysis 5. Risk Assessment 6. Mitigation Strategies 7. Monitoring and Review By conducting a phishing risk assessment, organisations can proactively identify and mitigate vulnerabilities to reduce the likelihood of falling victim to phishing attack
-
Jafar Hasan, CISSP
CISSP | CC | ISO 27001:2022 Lead Auditor | CRTP | CEH | (ISC)² Candidate | Information Security Consultant | Bug Bounty Hunter
Conduct a comprehensive assessment to identify potential phishing risks within your organization. Evaluate factors such as the likelihood of phishing attacks, susceptibility of employees to social engineering tactics, existing security controls and procedures, and the potential impact of successful phishing incidents. Analyze past phishing incidents, if available, to identify common patterns and vulnerabilities. Use the findings from the risk assessment to prioritize areas for improvement and tailor your phishing awareness and prevention efforts to address specific risks.
-
Aidan Dickenson
LinkedIn Cybersecurity Top Voice | I help UK businesses achieve impenetrable security through cutting-edge cybersecurity solutions.
Conduct a phishing risk assessment to pinpoint vulnerabilities and threats. Employ tools like PhishTank for simulation, MXToolBox for email security audits, DNSStuff for DNS analysis, and KnowBe4 for social engineering tests. These tools assess your email security, domain reputation, staff awareness, and potential attack vectors, providing a solid foundation for tailoring your phishing prevention strategies.
The third step is to implement phishing prevention measures to reduce your exposure and impact of phishing attacks. You can use various measures to prevent phishing, such as email filtering, domain authentication, encryption, multi-factor authentication, or backup and recovery. These measures can help you block malicious emails, verify the sender's identity, protect your data, enhance your login security, or restore your system in case of a breach.
-
Craig McDonald
We stop email threats others miss 🛡️ mailguard365.com | Enhance your Microsoft 365 security | Trusted by startups and industry leaders like Porsche | Endorsed by Satya Nadella | Non-techie CEO
Implement robust email filtering solutions to automatically detect and block suspicious emails containing phishing attempts. Advanced email filtering technologies analyze email content, attachments, and sender reputation to identify and quarantine phishing emails before they reach employees' inboxes, reducing the risk of successful phishing attacks.
-
Ajinkya G.
Experienced Enterprise Infrastructure Architect | Leading Complex Projects | IT Strategy and Solutions Expert | Cloud, Virtualization, IT Security, Modern Workplace
One crucial aspect is recognizing the importance of implementing robust measures to safeguard the users against phishing attempts. Incorporating mechanisms such as SPF (Sender Policy Framework), DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail), DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance), URL Rewriting, and external email tagging is imperative. These measures act as formidable barriers, significantly reducing users' susceptibility to falling prey to phishing attacks.
-
Umang Mehta
25x LinkedIn Top Voice 🏆 | Global Delivery Head | CISO | CISA | Global Thought Leader Top 10 IT Leadership | Global Top 50 CyberSecurity | SOC Expert | CySA+ | GICAST | PCI DSS | DFE | EHE | Writer | Researcher
The importance of implementing phishing prevention measures, such as email filtering, domain authentication, encryption, multi-factor authentication, and backup and recovery, to reduce exposure and impact of phishing attacks.
-
Jafar Hasan, CISSP
CISSP | CC | ISO 27001:2022 Lead Auditor | CRTP | CEH | (ISC)² Candidate | Information Security Consultant | Bug Bounty Hunter
Implement technical controls and security measures to prevent phishing attacks from being successful. Deploy email filtering and anti-phishing solutions to detect and block malicious emails before they reach employees' inboxes. Enable multi-factor authentication (MFA) to add an extra layer of security for accessing sensitive systems and data. Regularly update and patch software to mitigate vulnerabilities that could be exploited in phishing attacks. Implement domain-based authentication protocols such as DMARC to prevent email spoofing and domain impersonation.
-
Aidan Dickenson
LinkedIn Cybersecurity Top Voice | I help UK businesses achieve impenetrable security through cutting-edge cybersecurity solutions.
Implement phishing prevention measures to mitigate exposure and impact. Utilize email filtering to block malicious emails, domain authentication to verify sender identities, encryption to protect data, multi-factor authentication (MFA) to bolster login security, and backup and recovery solutions to restore systems after a breach. These strategies form a comprehensive defense against phishing attacks, safeguarding your organization's digital assets.
The fourth step is to provide phishing awareness training to educate your employees about the signs and consequences of phishing and how to avoid falling victim to it. You can use various formats and methods to provide phishing awareness training, such as online courses, videos, quizzes, games, or newsletters. These methods can help you increase your employees' knowledge, skills, and confidence in recognizing and reporting phishing attempts.
-
Umang Mehta
25x LinkedIn Top Voice 🏆 | Global Delivery Head | CISO | CISA | Global Thought Leader Top 10 IT Leadership | Global Top 50 CyberSecurity | SOC Expert | CySA+ | GICAST | PCI DSS | DFE | EHE | Writer | Researcher
The importance of providing phishing awareness training to employees through various formats and methods, such as online courses, videos, quizzes, games, and newsletters, to increase knowledge, skills, and confidence in recognizing and reporting phishing attempts.
-
Jason Soper
Cybersecurity Guardian | Safeguarding Clinics & Patients | Defend Boldly. Rest Easy.
Phishing awareness training is a great way to equip employees with crucial knowledge to recognize and avoid phishing scams. This in turn, reduces the risk of data breaches and financial loss. On top of this, it can foster a vigilant workforce capable of identifying suspicious emails, links, and requests, thereby safeguarding sensitive information. Training boosts employee confidence in handling potential threats and promotes a culture of cybersecurity, making it a key defense layer against cyber attacks. You can have the greatest systems in place, but the weakest link will always be human error. Awareness Training is a great way to combat this.
-
Chris Wojzechowski
Geschäftsführender Gesellschafter bei AWARE7 GmbH | Experte für Informationssicherheit
Running a phishing simulation is only half the battle. Interpreting the results correctly and deriving the appropriate measures from them is the other half. In doing so, you should always check what measures have already been implemented in the past, review the success of these measures and examine whether the subsequent measures fulfill the goal of increasing awareness.
-
Jafar Hasan, CISSP
CISSP | CC | ISO 27001:2022 Lead Auditor | CRTP | CEH | (ISC)² Candidate | Information Security Consultant | Bug Bounty Hunter
Develop and deliver comprehensive phishing awareness training programs for employees at all levels of the organization. Cover topics such as recognizing phishing emails, identifying social engineering tactics, verifying the authenticity of requests, and reporting suspicious emails or incidents. Utilize engaging and interactive training materials, such as online modules, videos, quizzes, and real-world examples, to reinforce key concepts and promote active learning. Tailor training content to different roles and departments within the organization to address specific phishing risks and challenges they may face.
-
Aidan Dickenson
LinkedIn Cybersecurity Top Voice | I help UK businesses achieve impenetrable security through cutting-edge cybersecurity solutions.
Provide phishing awareness training to educate employees on phishing signs and prevention. Utilize online courses, videos, quizzes, interactive games, and newsletters to increase knowledge, skills, and confidence in identifying and reporting phishing attempts. Engaging and diverse training formats can significantly enhance employees' ability to recognize and avoid phishing threats, contributing to a more secure organizational environment.
The fifth step is to run phishing simulation campaigns to test your employees' behavior and response to realistic phishing scenarios. You can use various tools and platforms to run phishing simulation campaigns, such as email templates, landing pages, forms, or reports. These tools can help you create and send customized phishing emails, track and measure your employees' actions, and provide immediate feedback and guidance.
-
Umang Mehta
25x LinkedIn Top Voice 🏆 | Global Delivery Head | CISO | CISA | Global Thought Leader Top 10 IT Leadership | Global Top 50 CyberSecurity | SOC Expert | CySA+ | GICAST | PCI DSS | DFE | EHE | Writer | Researcher
The significance of running phishing simulation campaigns using various tools and platforms, such as email templates, landing pages, forms, and reports, to test employees' behavior and response to realistic phishing scenarios and provide immediate feedback and guidance.
-
Jafar Hasan, CISSP
CISSP | CC | ISO 27001:2022 Lead Auditor | CRTP | CEH | (ISC)² Candidate | Information Security Consultant | Bug Bounty Hunter
Conduct regular phishing simulation campaigns to test employees' awareness and response to phishing attacks. Create realistic phishing email templates that mimic common tactics used by attackers, such as urgent requests for password resets, fake invoices, or spoofed emails from trusted sources. Monitor employees' interactions with simulated phishing emails, including click rates, submission of credentials, and reporting of suspicious emails. Use the results to identify areas for improvement, provide targeted feedback and coaching to employees, and reinforce training concepts.
-
Aidan Dickenson
LinkedIn Cybersecurity Top Voice | I help UK businesses achieve impenetrable security through cutting-edge cybersecurity solutions.
Run phishing simulation campaigns to test employees' reactions to realistic phishing scenarios. Employ tools such as usecure, KnowBe4, and PhishMe, which provide email templates, landing pages, forms, and detailed reports. These platforms allow for the creation of tailored phishing emails, tracking employee responses, and offering immediate feedback and training. Such simulations are vital for gauging the effectiveness of your phishing awareness programs and pinpointing areas needing further instruction.
-
Chris Wojzechowski
Geschäftsführender Gesellschafter bei AWARE7 GmbH | Experte für Informationssicherheit
When carrying out a phishing simulation, you should start low at the beginning. This serves to define the lower limit. Are people already reacting and interacting with non-personalized, general emails? Then immediate measures to create general awareness are recommended. It should also be checked what should happen after a link. Is it appropriate to provide information directly or should a login page be presented? This serves to determine how high the willingness is to disclose login data on potentially malicious websites. Recreating phishing emails and websites can be a time-consuming task. Especially when the measures are individualized.
-
Timo Sablowski
Cyber Security Consultant | Hacker | Digital Defender
Es ist wichtig, genau zu planen, welche Art von Simulationen wann und über welchen Zeitraum durchgeführt werden sollen. Dabei ist zu beachten, dass eine einzige Kampagne nicht ausreicht, um ein realistisches Bild zu bekommen. Dieselbe Phishing-Kampagne kann je nach Tageszeit, aktuellem Stresslevel der Mitarbeitenden und manchmal auch einfach durch Glück unterschiedlich erfolgreich sein. Um einen Überblick über den potenziell erfolgreichen Angriffsvektor „Phishing“ zu erhalten, sind mehrere Simulationen über einen längeren Zeitraum notwendig. Zusätzlich sollten Standard-Phishing-Mails aus gängigen Frameworks mit spezifischen, auf das Unternehmen zugeschnittenen Kampagnen kombiniert werden.
The sixth step is to review and improve your program based on the data and feedback you collect from your phishing risk assessment, prevention measures, awareness training, and simulation campaigns. You can use various methods to review and improve your program, such as data analysis, benchmarking, gap analysis, or action planning. These methods can help you identify your strengths and weaknesses, compare your performance with industry standards or best practices, prioritize your improvement areas, and implement your improvement actions.
-
Nebojsha Antic 🌟
🌟 230x LinkedIn Top Voice | BI Developer - Kin + Carta | 🌐 Certified Google Professional Cloud Architect and Data Engineer | Microsoft 📊 AI Engineer, Fabric Analytics Engineer, Azure Administrator, Data Scientist
- 📊 Conduct regular phishing simulations to measure employee awareness and response rates. - 🛠️ Analyze simulation results to identify common weaknesses and trends in employee responses. - 🔄 Benchmark your program against industry standards and best practices to gauge effectiveness. - 📈 Use gap analysis to pinpoint specific areas needing improvement and develop targeted training initiatives. - 📑 Gather feedback from employees to refine training materials and methods, ensuring continuous improvement and relevance.
-
Umang Mehta
25x LinkedIn Top Voice 🏆 | Global Delivery Head | CISO | CISA | Global Thought Leader Top 10 IT Leadership | Global Top 50 CyberSecurity | SOC Expert | CySA+ | GICAST | PCI DSS | DFE | EHE | Writer | Researcher
Regularly assessing and fine-tuning your phishing prevention program not only bolsters your defense mechanisms but also fosters a culture of cybersecurity awareness and resilience within your organization. By leveraging data-driven insights and strategic planning, you can proactively address vulnerabilities, adapt to emerging threats, and continuously improve your defenses against phishing attacks.
-
Jafar Hasan, CISSP
CISSP | CC | ISO 27001:2022 Lead Auditor | CRTP | CEH | (ISC)² Candidate | Information Security Consultant | Bug Bounty Hunter
Continuously review and evaluate the effectiveness of your phishing awareness and prevention program. Analyze metrics such as click rates, reporting rates, and incident response times to assess the program's impact and identify areas for enhancement. Solicit feedback from employees to understand their perceptions of the program and areas where they may need additional support or resources. Incorporate lessons learned from phishing simulation campaigns and real-world incidents into program updates and refinements. Regularly review and update training materials, phishing templates, and security controls to adapt to evolving threats and ensure the program remains effective over time.
-
Laura H.
Inspiring servant leaders and building inclusive teams
Keep in mind, social engineering is a form of psychological manipulation that tricks humans into making security mistakes or giving away sensitive information. It relies on human error instead of software vulnerabilities. Human error is much less predictable, making it harder to detect and block than attacks on hardware/software. The most common form of social engineering is phishing - using email or malicious websites to solicit personal information by posing as a trustworthy organization or person. It exploits human emotions. Spear phishing targets a narrower audience, hence the spear. For example, a phishing attack that I have seen was the email sent posing as the CEO of the company. It was a very coordinated phishing attack.
Rate this article
More relevant reading
-
Security AwarenessHow do you simulate phishing attacks to improve security awareness?
-
CybersecurityWhat are the most important metrics to track for phishing incidents?
-
Information SecurityHow can you improve employee awareness of phishing attacks through simulations?
-
Security TrainingHow do you train your staff to detect and prevent phishing attacks?