3CPO (CIO, CISO, CPO) CISSP, CISM - Helping nonprofits leverage technology to do more, do better and be more secure. Also, I regularly collaborate with a potato.
Earlier this week, I purchased Amanda Gorman's powerful inaugural poem. Less than a day later, I learned that a Florida school has restricted access to it. I want to be clear, the school did not "ban" the poem. It moved it to a section of the library designated for middle schoolers as opposed to elementary-age children. Calling it a ban would be disingenuous. The school took this action based on the request from a single person, a person who claimed the poem contains "hate messages". The person also misidentified the author of the poem as Oprah Winfrey (who, to be fair, did write a foreword for the published poem). The person submitted the request to the school on March 29th of this year. On March 31st, just two days later, the same person promoted "Protocols of the Elders of Zion" on Facebook (for those not aware, it is a centuries-old antisemitic conspiracy theory). (I should clarify. Facebook is not a centuries-old antisemitic conspiracy theory. Rather, it is a social media platform where this person promoted "Protocols of the Elders of Zion," which is a centuries-old anti-semitic conspiracy theory.) I should also point that I am Jewish, so "centuries-old anti-semitic conspiracy theories" are, in some respects, about me. One of the passages of Amanda Gorman's poem this person felt contained "hate messages" was this: "Somehow we do it. Somehow we weathered and witnessed a nation that isn’t broken, but simply unfinished." Sometimes it seems to me that people feel like they need to believe one or another thing about our country. In one camp: This is a great country. In the other camp: This country has issues. Why can't it be both? As someone who struggles with feelings of shame and self-hatred, my life has been profoundly changed by dialectical thinking, or the ability to hold two seemingly contradictory ideas at once. Can't this be both a great country and, as Amanda Gorman wrote, "unfinished"? Can't we be proud of the progress we have made and the things we have done and also want better? Okay, I have to get back to work on the space lasers that turn the frogs gay. Happy Friday, everyone.
Josh, I almost never comment on Linkedin or anywhere else but I was compelled to say something after reading this compelling mini essay. Please do write more, this is relevant, beautiful and thought provoking!
spot on Josh, the universe is "unfinished"
While the situation you write about makes me sad, it makes me feel good to be able to read such an informative and well considered take on it.
Thank you Josh for your eloquence. Heartbreaking times in USA continue. #poetry
Porque no los dos? 🤔
Well said…..
Well said
Thanks for being you, Josh! You're an amazing person to be.
spot on, Josh
VP of Data Strategy at RoundTable Technology PMP, CIPP/US
1yThank you for taking the time to write this. I needed to stop, take a breath, and read this story in your words. Earlier it had been another mortifying story in a news scroll that leaves me numb. Reading your words here, I got to access my feelings around this, which is important.