Lorna's Reviews > Elon Musk

Elon Musk by Walter Isaacson
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
6700518
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: biography, aviation, history, social-history

Where do I begin to add some thoughts about the latest book, Elon Musk, by one of our most renowned biographers, Walter Isaacson, but with his words in the Acknowledgements of his book as follows:

"Elon Musk allowed me to shadow him for two years, invited me to sit in on his meetings, indulged scores of interviews and late-night conversations, provided emails and texts, and encouraged his friends, colleagues, family members, adversaries and ex-wives to talk to me. He did not ask, nor did he, read this book before it was published, and he exercised no control over it."


Having written interesting and riveting biographies of Leonardo da Vinci, Albert Einstein, Henry Kissinger, Steve Jobs and Jennifer Doudna to name a few, perhaps Walter Isaacson was the perfect person to attempt to write the compelling story of one of our most brilliant innovators and engineers that has transformed the world, particularly in the realm of space exploration, mass production of electric cars designed to combat adverse changes in our earth caused by climate change, and in the field of artificial intelligence. This brilliant man-child, prone to mood changes which would immediately
change the characterization of moment, and described as his demon-mode eruptions that left rubble in its wake. But then Walter Isaacson asks in the last page of this book whether a restrained Musk could accomplish as much as a Musk unbound? Once again, Isaacson's words:

"But would a restrained Musk accomplish as much as a Musk unbound? Is being unfiltered and untethered integral to who he is? Could you get the rockets to orbit or the transition to electric vehicles without accepting all aspects of him, hinged and unhinged? Sometimes great innovators are risk-seeking man-children who resist potty training. They can be reckless, cringeworthy, sometimes even toxic. They can also be crazy. Crazy enough to think they can change the world."


The biography of Elon Musk begins with the prescient words of Steve Jobs: The people who are crazy enough to think they can change the world are the ones who do. It is apparent in this book that Elon Musk developed a siege mentality that included an attraction for storm and drama. Musk thrived on crises, deadlines, and wild surges of work. I was so struck when Musk was determined that he was going to increase the production of Tesla automobiles and was working intricately with others to change certain design elements that would eliminate slow-downs in the production cycle, often using toy cars to resolve issues in the design. And during this critical time over a three-day period, Elon Musk stayed on the production line catching a few hours sleep on the floor when he could. Needless to say, his wild goal of the production of 5000 Tesla automobiles per week was accomplished. It is that kind of drive that is seen in Musk throughout this book, and he expects no less from those around him.

"He had never been a captain of a sports team or the leader of a gang of friends, and he lacked an instinct for camaraderie. Like Steve Jobs, he genuinely did not care if he offended or intimidated the people he worked with, as long as he drove them to accomplish feats they thought were impossible."


Another big part of Musk's story for me was how he led the world in space exploration. It was 2010 when Barack Obama met Elon Musk at Cape Canaveral to determine what SpaceX was accomplishing in the space program. It was Musk's chance to prove that he wasn't nuts when in June 2010 when the Falcon 9, the first unmanned test voyage was successfully launched into orbit. The launch went perfectly and Elon Musk joined his jubilant team at an all-night party on a Coco Beach pier. Elon Musk called it a "vindication of what the president had proposed. It was also a vindication of Space X." The next big test, scheduled for later in 2010, was to show that Space X could not only launch an unmanned capsule into orbit but also return it to earth safely.

"As awesome as it was, Musk had a sobering realization. The Mercury program had accomplished similar feats fifty years earlier, before either he or Obama had been born. America was just catching up with its older self."


And I'm going to end with the portion of the book when he was nominated by Time magazine as Person of the Year in 2021.

"The magazine's accolade marked a peak in his popularity. In 2021, he became the richest person in the world, SpaceX became the first private company to send a civilian crew into orbit, and Tesla reached a trillion-dollar market value by leading the world's auto industry in a historic shift into the era of electric vehicles. 'Few individuals have had more influence than Musk on life on Earth, and potentially life off Earth, too,' Time's editor Ed Felsenthal wrote. The 'Financial Times' also named him Person of the Year, stating 'Musk is staking a claim to be the most genuinely innovative entrepreneur of his generation.'"


Addendum: It is now November 17, 2023 and I feel that I must amend my review to reflect the anti-Semitic views that are now being put forward by X and Elon Musk. I am horrified at the hatred and racism that has been espoused on this platform by Elon Musk. And I stand by Israel.
61 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Elon Musk.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 10, 2023 – Shelved
September 10, 2023 – Shelved as: to-read
September 10, 2023 – Shelved as: biography
September 16, 2023 – Shelved as: aviation
October 5, 2023 – Started Reading
October 5, 2023 – Shelved as: on-deck
October 5, 2023 – Shelved as: social-history
October 5, 2023 – Shelved as: history
October 10, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-26 of 26 (26 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Ken (new)

Ken Was the Twitter thing too late to get into the book? Or Musk's political inclinations, which give him political leverage as owner of Twitter X and Space X (as exemplified in Ukraine's need of his satellites and his ambivalence about that)? That's what would really interest me.


Lorna Ken wrote: "Was the Twitter thing too late to get into the book? Or Musk's political inclinations, which give him political leverage as owner of Twitter X and Space X (as exemplified in Ukraine's need of his s..."

Thank you, Ken. And yes, all of that was covered in the book but I ran out of steam doing the review because there was so much. As I understand it, Elon Musk felt very strongly about supporting the Ukraine with Spacelink, part of SpaceX. However, when he was told by a Russian counterpart that if Ukraine invaded Crimea as they felt they were planning, there would be a nuclear war. Musk spoke with both Jake Sullivan and possibly General Milley, and at some point Musk disabled the satellites supplying Crimea but not to the rest of the Ukraine.
As for the hostile takeover of Twitter, now X, it was very interesting reading. He felt Twitter was a bloated company and he initially cut the work force by 85% and then later cut it again. It remains to be seen what happens with Twitter since it is a social medium, essentially the global public square, not especially in what one would think of as Elon Musk's wheelhouse. He still firmly believes that every company is best run by engineers. So Ken, it is looking like you may have to read the book! :)


Vanessa A terrific review, Lorna! I thought Isaacson covered a lot in his book about Musk, which to me seems a daunting and complicated task. I like the quotes from the book that you've included in your review.


Lorna Vanessa Newville PA wrote: "A terrific review, Lorna! I thought Isaacson covered a lot in his book about Musk, which to me seems a daunting and complicated task. I like the quotes from the book that you've included in your re..."

Thank you for your kind comments, Vanessa. And I agree that Walter Isaacson did a beautiful job in navigating the troubled threads of the life of Elon Musk. It was a truly amazing job.


message 5: by Mark (new)

Mark  Porton What a compelling review Lorna, Musk has certainly achieved so much, and he's quite a polarising character too - something he probably couldn't give a toss about, as you touch on in your review (.....being indifferent to the opinions of others). But, the main thing I got from your review is you singing the praises of biographer Walter Isaacson. I have his Steve Jobs biography on my shelf, and I was going to return it to the book exchange, as I didn't really fancy it. See I've never heard of Isaacson (WHAT!!!!.....I hear you saying), well I do know about him now so I just sprinted over to my bookcase and have rescued it from my "rubbish shelf". Phew!

We learn something new everyday don't we? 🤗


Lorna Mark wrote: "What a compelling review Lorna, Musk has certainly achieved so much, and he's quite a polarising character too - something he probably couldn't give a toss about, as you touch on in your review (....."

Thank you for your kind comment, Mark. And yes to you rescuing your Steve Jobs book by Walter Isaacson, he does these bad boys so well. After reading both of those books, I have to say that I think that Elon Musk is at his core, the kinder man. He is still a young man and what milestones he has in his future, we only hope.


message 7: by Nocturnalux (last edited Oct 12, 2023 07:19PM) (new)

Nocturnalux Yeah, Musk's trans child might have a thing or two to say about how "kinder" the dude is. A young man, he's in his fifties!


Lorna Nocturnalux wrote: "Yeah, Musk's trans child might have a thing or two to say about how "kinder" the dude is. A young man, he's in his fifties!"

Thank you for your comment, Nocturnalux. Elon Musk has been very open about his daughter and has reached out to her. That has been one of his heartbreaks. From the book I got the feeling that he was quite open to his son transitioning to a daughter. We can all hope that one day they are able to reunite.


message 9: by Jaidee (new)

Jaidee Excellent review Lorna !


Lorna Jaidee wrote: "Excellent review Lorna !"

Thank you, Jaidee. Walter Isaacson did a beautiful job.


Emma Griffioen incredible review! i will be adding this to my tbr for sure


Lorna emma griffioen! wrote: "incredible review! i will be adding this to my tbr for sure"

Thank you so much, Emma. It was an amazing book. I will look forward to your thoughts.


message 13: by Lori (new)

Lori  Keeton Excellent review, Lorna! I’m glad you liked this!
My IRL book club is voting on biographies/autobios next and this is on the list. So is Stanley Tucci’s which would be interesting.


Lorna Lori wrote: "Excellent review, Lorna! I’m glad you liked this!
My IRL book club is voting on biographies/autobios next and this is on the list. So is Stanley Tucci’s which would be interesting."


Thank you so much, Lori. I have read both books, and while I love Stanley Tucci, the biography by Walter Isaacson, Elon Musk, is such a powerful book. Please let me know what your book club decides, and the reaction. ):


message 15: by Julie (new)

Julie G Lady,
Your reads are diverse!! What a lively reading response.
(I love that Elon Musk didn't read the book before it was published. Talk about a lesson in Zen Buddhism!)
xoxo


Lorna Julie wrote: "Lady,
Your reads are diverse!! What a lively reading response.
(I love that Elon Musk didn't read the book before it was published. Talk about a lesson in Zen Buddhism!)
xoxo"


Thank you, dear Julie. And I was impressed by that as well. While I was never an Elon Musk fan, I was so shaken by this book by Walter Isaacson of this man on the cutting edge of space, electric cars and artificial intelligence and his dedication to the process. And I am now watching this man with hopeful expectations. So wonderful to hear from you, my friend.


message 17: by Mark (new)

Mark “One of our most brilliant innovators and engineers that has transformed the world…” I just don’t see it. Rather, Musk has just wasted our time and should, in the words of an actually brilliant intellectual, be fined for doing so. Dude has done nothing but be in the right place at the right time with billions in surplus capital to burn.


Lorna Thank you for your thoughts, Mark. I will grant you that Elon Musk is a prickly sort of dude, but all in all, he has produced amazing results with Tesla and Space X. You may want to pick up the book. . .


message 19: by Dmitri (last edited Nov 22, 2023 11:44AM) (new)

Dmitri Great review Lorna! I must say I don’t like the man Musk and wonder when we might call ‘the platform formerly known as Twitter’ simply X as it takes up extra terabytes of data center storage every time it is written. On the other hand he did become the wealthiest person in the world which isn’t easy.


Lorna Dmitri wrote: "Great review Lorna! I must say I don’t like the man Musk and wonder when we might call ‘the platform formerly known as Twitter’ simply X as it takes up extra terabytes of date center storage every ..."

Thank you, Dmitri. A very complicated man, indeed. I didn't particularly like Musk either but I was intrigued with his achievements with Space X, Tesla and AI. However, X may cause him more problems. Walter Isaacson did a wonderful job in this biography, a very honest portrayal, I thought.


message 21: by Alan (new)

Alan I enjoy all your reviews, Lorna, this being no exception. I'm deeply troubled by his antisemitism; this inhumanity will forever cloud my opinion of him. Musk and Henry Ford will be regarded as automotive pioneers but I will regard them first as brazen public antisemites. I have never owned a Ford product or Volkswagen for that matter, and I will never drive a Tesla.


Lorna Alan wrote: "I enjoy all your reviews, Lorna, this being no exception. I'm deeply troubled by his antisemitism; this inhumanity will forever cloud my opinion of him. Musk and Henry Ford will be regarded as auto..."

Thank you for your most kind comment, Alan. And I agree with your choice in cars, I have never owned any of those cars either, but a Mercedes-Benz is waiting in the garage. . . .


Margaret M - (too far behind to catch up although trying to spend more time on GR) This is the most enticing and well rounded review I’ve read about this book. Wonderful Lorna 💖


Lorna Ahh Margaret, thank you for your wonderful comment. I appreciate it.


message 25: by lautesbrot (new)

lautesbrot Uhm, yes antisemitism is trash and hilding him accountable for that is important. But calling him as a great innovator? He is one of the oligarchs who gets money from states just to build factories that need a TON, and I mean A TON OF WATER that should be used by the people to drink and not to produce cars which yes are electric but we do not need any more cars in this society! This is not innovative, this is truly conservative.


Lorna lautesbrot wrote: "Uhm, yes antisemitism is trash and hilding him accountable for that is important. But calling him as a great innovator? He is one of the oligarchs who gets money from states just to build factories..."

That is your opinion. After reading this comprehensive biography by Walter Isaacson, it is my opinion that Elon Musk is one of our great innovators, not only his achievements with Tesla but in the area of space exploration and artificial intelligence. You may want to read the book.


back to top